⚔️HEAD-TO-HEAD

Hayley Matthews vs Smriti Mandhana — International Fantasy Cricket Stats Comparison

Who is better — Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana?

Smriti Mandhana has the edge on the headline numbers: Smriti Mandhana leads on T20I batting (4,867 runs, avg 31.0). Full T20I, ODI, Test and IPL stats are below.

Hayley Matthews (West Indies Women) has 3,382 T20I runs at avg 29.2 in 127 matches. Smriti Mandhana (India Women) has 4,867 T20I runs at avg 31.0 in 179 matches. Head-to-head batting, bowling & fielding across T20I, ODI & Test.

Full season · batting · bowling · fielding · MOTM · form

TweetWhatsApp
PLAYER 1
🏏
Hayley Matthews
🌴 WIW · 10 cr
VS
PLAYER 2
🏏
Smriti Mandhana
🇮🇳 INDW · 10 cr
🏏
Hayley Matthews
🌴 West Indies Women
AR
10 cr
Credits
85
Avg Pts
194
Best FP
150.3
Pts/Cr
469
Total Runs
28
Total Wkts
🏏
Smriti Mandhana
🇮🇳 India Women
BAT🏅 2× MOTM
10 cr
Credits
73
Avg Pts
229
Best FP
105.5
Pts/Cr
843
Total Runs
0
Total Wkts
📈 Slight Edge
🏏 Hayley Matthews
12 higher avg pts · 194 best fantasy score
🏏 Hayley Matthews
VS
🏏 Smriti Mandhana
T20I Career Overview
127Matches179
🏏 Batting
3382Runs4867
29.16Batting Avg31.00
3Centuries2
21Half-Centuries37
53Sixes 🔴87
132
Best Score
124
🎳 Bowling
130Wickets0
18.97Bowling Avg—
05-Wkt Hauls0
4/10
Best Figures
—
Source: Cricsheet (cricsheet.org, CC BY 4.0) · International matches only

Hayley Matthews vs Smriti Mandhana — Stat Comparison Table

Head-to-head numbers at a glance. Higher value is highlighted in green (lower is better for economy and bowling/batting averages).

IPL season stats
StatisticHayley MatthewsSmriti Mandhana
Matches2020
Avg fantasy points8573
Best fantasy score194229
Runs469843
Strike rate97.3118.1
Fours54103
Sixes824
Half-centuries (50+)14
Centuries (100+)02
Highest score56153
Wickets280
Economy rate6.850.00
Best spell (wkts)40
Catches411
Total dismissals412
International career — T20I
StatisticHayley MatthewsSmriti Mandhana
Matches127179
Runs33824867
Batting average29.1631.00
Centuries (100+)32
Half-centuries (50+)2137
Wickets1300
Bowling average18.97—

📋 Format by format

T20I. Hayley Matthews has played 127 T20Is and Smriti Mandhana 179. Hayley Matthews has 3,382 runs at 29.2, against 4,867 at 31.0 for Smriti Mandhana, so Smriti Mandhana has scored more. Hundreds: Hayley Matthews 3, Smriti Mandhana 2. Fifties: 21 and 37. Hayley Matthews also bowls: 130 wickets, while Smriti Mandhana has not taken a T20I wicket.

ODI. Hayley Matthews has played 111 ODIs and Smriti Mandhana 120. Hayley Matthews has 3,892 runs at 38.2, against 5,411 at 47.9 for Smriti Mandhana, so Smriti Mandhana has scored more. Hundreds: Hayley Matthews 14, Smriti Mandhana 14. Fifties: 8 and 35. With the ball, Hayley Matthews has 142 wickets and Smriti Mandhana 1 at 7.83; Hayley Matthews has more wickets.

International numbers up to 30 August 2026.

Stats updated
⚡ Strengths & Captaincy Pick
🏏 Hayley Matthews
✓ More wickets
✓ Higher avg fantasy pts
🏏 Smriti Mandhana
✓ Superior run-scorer
✓ Higher strike rate
✓ More big-hitting sixes
✓ More MOTM awards
👑 Captaincy Recommendation
C: 🏏 Hayley Matthews
85 avg pts · 194 best · 0 MOTM
VC: 🏏 Smriti Mandhana
Captaining Hayley Matthews gives you 2× pts. Always verify playing XI before locking.
📝 T20I Career Comparison

Hayley Matthews vs Smriti Mandhana — T20I is a highly-debated cricket matchup. Below are their T20I career highlights.

T20I career: Hayley Matthews has scored 3,382 T20I runs in 127 matches at an average of 29.16, with 3 centuries. She has also taken 130 T20I wickets at an average of 18.97.

T20I career: Smriti Mandhana has scored 4,867 T20I runs in 179 matches at an average of 31.00, with 2 centuries.

Fantasy Impact: From a pure fantasy perspective, Hayley Matthews is the stronger pick with an average of 85 pts per game in recent fantasy cricket. Always check the playing XI and toss before locking in your captain.

Stats are sourced from international career records. Compare more players using our Player Comparison Tool.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Who has better fantasy stats — Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana?

Based on recent data, Hayley Matthews has the edge with a higher average of 85 fantasy points per game. Smriti Mandhana leads in runs scored (843 runs). Overall Hayley Matthews is the stronger fantasy pick this season.

Hayley Matthews vs Smriti Mandhana — who is a better fantasy captain?

Hayley Matthews is the recommended fantasy captain pick, averaging 85 pts per game with a best score of 229 pts. As captain you earn 2× points, so choosing the player in better form is crucial. Always check the toss and playing XI before finalising your captain.

Who has a better strike rate — Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana?

Smriti Mandhana has the superior batting strike rate this season (118.1), making them more valuable in T20 cricket where quick scoring is rewarded with bonus fantasy points.

What is the price difference between Hayley Matthews and Smriti Mandhana?

Hayley Matthews costs 10 Cr and Smriti Mandhana costs 10 Cr in current fantasy. The player with lower credits who delivers similar points gives you better value, freeing up budget for other expensive picks.

How many MOTM awards have Hayley Matthews and Smriti Mandhana won?

Hayley Matthews has won 0 Man of the Match awards and Smriti Mandhana has won 2 MOTM awards. MOTM winners earn +25 bonus fantasy points, making them extremely valuable.

Should I pick Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana in my fantasy XI?

If you can only pick one, Hayley Matthews is the statistically stronger fantasy cricket pick this season. However, consider the match conditions — if West Indies Women are favourites, more of their players will contribute, and vice versa for India Women. Use this comparison tool to make an informed decision every match.

Who has more T20I runs, Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana?

Smriti Mandhana has more T20I runs: Hayley Matthews has 3,382 in 127 matches (average 29.2) and Smriti Mandhana has 4,867 in 179 (average 31.0).

Who has more ODI runs, Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana?

Smriti Mandhana has more ODI runs: Hayley Matthews has 3,892 in 111 matches (average 38.2) and Smriti Mandhana has 5,411 in 120 (average 47.9).
READY TO PLAY?
Pick Matthews & Mandhana in your fantasy XI
Free to play · No prize pool · Just bragging rights
Build XI →

SETTLE IT IN A GAME

Numbers only get you so far. Pick a side — Hayley Matthews or Smriti Mandhana — and see who actually delivers.

Found an issue or have a suggestion? Contact us — we’d love to hear from you.

CricketDreamCRICKETDREAM FANTASY
© 2026 CricketDream · Fantasy Cricket Platform · Built for cricket fans
Disclaimer: This platform is intended for users aged 18 years and above only. CricketDream is a free, skill-based fantasy cricket platform for entertainment purposes only. No monetary transactions or prizes are involved. Not affiliated with, endorsed by, licensed by, or sponsored by the BCCI, the IPL, any IPL franchise, or any other cricket governing body. All team names, player names, and logos are property of their respective owners.
⚽ ALSO INTO FOOTBALL?
Play Fantasy Football, Draft & Predictor — on FootballDream.in
🎯 Predictor📋 Team Draft👤 Player Draft
Play Now → footballdream.in